MAIN PG PREVIEW GET THE BOOK CRITICS SURVEY INDEX GUESTBOOK THE AUTHOR
Algae

I have this brown.layer that's covering some of my coralline algae -- it's no thicker, but is expanding... how can I control it?

diatom s remnants of a new tank cycle.. possibly feeding too much. Control it with the usual methods as manual removal with a bottle brush hermits dislodge it some critters will eat it. Do you have new lamps? sometimes that can be an indication of failing this type of algae is the most common and "should" pretty much go away naturally if all other components are working such as the shimmer the tap water not overfeeding and having herbivorous (sp) livestock

Is it just a different kind of coralline?

no ;-) coralline is calcareous either pink or purple.



I have a new problem I have some hair algae I assume from the increase in light I have bought 7 hermit crabs and 2 turbo snails.. 1 died in about a week cant seem to keep snails alive very long...

Sometimes they Don't last long and are sensitive to any cycling ammonia/nitrite. Some are believe it or not poisoned by the algae. one out of 2 isn't that bad. 25 out of 50 then you may have a problem.

I am thinking of purchasing the Garf reef janitors 45 for $45 deal is this a good idea

Yea thats a good deal and GARF is a good place. The snails will be good for the tank and will reproduce pretty easily.

or should the algae settle down when it gets adjusted to the new light??? Are you using Ro or DI water? you should. You also should dose kalk *very* regularly make SURE you do that do you know about pickle lime? Its the same thing as kalk (its food grade calcium hydroxide) and dirt cheap like $1.40 per lb look for balls pickle lime or see my browser search faq for the address. So 2 things make sure you dose kalk for all evaporation water and use ro or di water and your algae will disappear.

Do I need to get some phosphate remover stuff?? No



I hear allot about algae problems associated with plenums over a period of time and It has happened to me. My recommended system is the Berlin and using eggcrate and the spraybar makes it a "Glorified Berlin" It works extremely well and of course I highly recommend it. It seems to me as a general observation that because these systems never really caught on that there must be a reason for it. *Most* hobbyists are economical and if a less expensive system would work it would be more widely used. I guess that's the basis or your question, I wish I could be more help and in the future (once the dust starts to settle) I may do some experiments with these systems

I have another tank that I have been cycling with live rock for two weeks. Its a 30 gallon with a plenum. 1" of crushed coral, 1" inch of sand and 1" of live sand. I have 25 lbs of live rock. My question is on one side the crushed coral has this brownish green almost algae like stuff growing.. What is it is it normal??? Yes, I mean its not like its supposed to happen but I wouldn't be surprised at a small algae outbreak sounds like a typical cyano bacteria caused by cycling. Are you using purified tap water? If not that will cause algae..

The reason why I write to you is that I'm curious if your book would help fish-only tank. I understand that if I maintain the fish tank like a reef tank fish is going to be very happy. However, fish creates a lot more waste than coral and invertebrate do, so there should be slightly different approaches to run fish tank.. I'm using 240 pounds of live rock to cycle my tank right now and basically I don't see my tank as a pure fish-only tank.

As far as your tank goes I think trying to have both worlds a [fish only] and [240 LB of live rock] can possibly lead to problems i.e.: Fish produce waste ammonia and phosphate ammonia will get broken down to nitrate and eventually nitrogen gas, but the phosphate will still have to be dealt with very strong skimming and if not dramatically reduced you may have substantial algae that will cover the rock. So if you have acquired the live rock I would suggest FAVORING reef principals (minimum fish) and lean in that direction. Really with all that rock in the tank I don't see allot of happy fish unless they are very small. IMO trying to have allot of fish may end up ruining allot of live rock.

Basic modern reef principals are

All the above will yield zero nitrates and manageable algae and a thriving reef tank Hope this helps your decision


I would like your opinion on using a NNR system with it. Was this system preferred before the new high efficiency skimmers were available?

I believe it was found to harbor denitrifying bacteria and very low nitrates and then deemed a breakthrough for denitrification. Years ago, It was thought to stuff as much live rock as could fit in the tank to achieve nitrification and denitrification (a little is good more must be better) the result was having hobbyists tanks that were setup for 1 yr. to 18 months to have unexplainable unmanageable algae outbreaks. This was then attributed to having too much rock where nutrients build up unseen.It also turned otherwise good quality rock to base rock as lighting wasn't able to get to the stacked rock. This meant a complete takedown and 75% water change and removal of un necessary rock. At that point a rule of thumb was established.


Potential problems with plenums

Yes, I too have had an persistent algae problem while running a NNR plenum system. This occurred at approx one year to 14 months. I “unscientifically” attributed the problem to detritus buildup and high nutrient levels. I then took the system down, re-setup with a bare bottom, raised rock system and the algae disappeared. I find this discussion very interesting regarding the “success” of this type of system. Can all this be a coincidence? I don't think so. This NNR as I understood it was to eliminate/drastically reduce waterchanges. A “too good to be true” system. NNR or natural nitrate reduction is, I would think, just what it says. We all know that nitrate will get reduced with the correct amount of “live” rock or sand in relation to the bio-load of the tank. It is my opinion using the *correct* amount will have a large role in the long term “success” of the aquarium. I use and recommend 1.5 to 1.75 lb. per gal. Using too much live sand or rock can trap debris/detritus going unseen and building up a food source for micro-algae as well as being unfavorably biologically dense for the enclosed system. In my system ( a55 gall) , the 1.75 “ approx sand thickness came out to be 80lbs or 1.45 lbs per gallon. I also added approx 50 lb of live rock bringing it to over 2.36 lbs per gallon. This leads me to believe that excessive biological medium ie:live sand or rock becomes “un-manageable” regarding nutrient build-up over extended periods of time. This is Jauberts patent site



The algae is green and grows so ridiculously fast that I'm afraid that it will suffocate the tank. It floats on the surface and pretty much stops surface water flow. It's kind of brought my operation to a halt. yes thats not good. at all I strongly suggest adding a surface skimmer box you should be able to find one at your local fish store or If you need some suggestions of suppliers on the net see my links page one of them will be happy to get something for you Eddie at monolith or Marc at Northcoast or Brian at Reefers mail them or call Untill then You "should" manually remove the algae you Don't have to be fanatical just get rid (dispose of) most of it.

(you need a surface skimmer box)

Is there an animal that eats surface algae.

No, You shouldn't have ANY surface algae

You should be "surface skimming" meaning ALL the water to feed your protein skimmer or filter should be taken from the surface of the tank. This is usually done with an overflow box or the tank drilled with a fitting thru the top back wall so as the water is getting pumped into the tank...it then overflows into this fitting or overflow box. So the water to feed the skimmer is taken from the surface and will eliminate your problem. This is the method used in 99% of reef systems



Algae

there's small amounts of bubble algae growing,

IME that's a sign of poor water. I assume by bubble you mean fairly large air bubbles forming on the rock and getting covered with a thin coat of algae...streaming upward to the top??? bad TW

Anyway, should I take the rocks with bubble algae on it out and remove the bulbs with tweezers?

IME there are 2 kings of bubble algae the above kind, the other REAL bubble algae is Valonia, this is small spherical shaped medium green in color looks and feels like an artificial grape.They tend to grow in clusters and this type can be individually picked off. These IME have been fairly easy to manage by hand and I doubt the type you are talking about as they take a while to form...unless the rock was loaded when you got it... I doubt that.

I scrubbed a few rocks yesterday, and it helped a lot, but it wasn't fun...

Again, IME and opinion it is unnecessary to remove the rock and scrub in a different bucket. When you put the rock back in (to the ????water you are back to square 1). You know how strongly feel about TWP for just this type of problem.Algae!

if I get a RO or DI unit and make all of my make-up water with it (or change some percentage of the water with filtered water), will the algae go away slowly, or will it keep growing once it starts? IMO It will go away FASTER with more water changed. I would do a 35 to 45% WC and then ONLY RO/DI for all water weather it be WC or Make up

I used carbon-filtered water to fill the tank previously. Maybe I should test for phosphates/silicates..? You are already IN. Most test kits unless very high quality wont/cant get reading low enough that will cause algae

Algae Blooms

causes I think I mentioned I changed my bulbs late and the algae bloomed.

Hummm...do you think its the lights? I know you do, but I think it may be from other sources. Your water...what type of TWP do you use and when was the last time the resin was changed? How much skimmate is the skimmer producing? A real lot? allot? some? not much? I know the lights are suspect BUT that situation doesn’t happen the way I’m hearing/observing it here I suspect water quality...from adding the new liverock and possible lesser than desired TWP along with the lights but I don’t think its the lights alone. I don’t want to be preachy after all you are there, I’m just trying to pass along my observation FWIW I have had B A D lights with No algae, then some changes to the tank rearranging adding stuff... TWP with bad resin THEN a severe out break of algae ALGAE! IME TWP will be the most significant contributor to hair algae

Manually removing algae

Well, its hard to get all of the algae...purchase a bottle brush, plastic approx 1 1/2inch diameter by 6 in length can be found in most domestic stores. Using that, you can catch the algae by twirling the brush exc. and removing it. Also strong algae magnets will work well on diatoms.

Algae

Depends on water quality you can have allot of wattage IF.... you have EXCELLENT WQ and are prepared for the expense of running it.(and or over lighting the tank) If the WQ slacks = algae poor WQ IMO is caused by inadequate initial TWP inadequate skimming (undersized) infrequent WC too many or too few fish too much or too little live rock live sand plenums silicate phosphate nitrate also IMO detritus buildup I think MH lighting is OK but I still favor FLO I think people think they are impressive with MH lighting if you NEED it for allot sps clams anemones fine but it can be overkill for the long run.

I have lots of green-hair algae just getting started

Are you using a Tap water purification system? RO or DI? Not using that will usually cause more hair algae than any tang(s) could/would eat.

Which tang (brown and green Algae eater would be nice)? but I'm open to any suggestion and may not be able to find one.

I would start with a yellow tang and or Sailfin tang very good algae eaters STAY AWAY from powder blue or powder brown tangs as the get ich if you look at them Another good tang is the hippo tang AKA surgeon fish

What Food for the tang, if I get one ? He'll have plenty of Algae for a while. I would start with marine Hikari flake or tetra marine flake supplemented here and there with a few shrimp pelletts. If you start out using basic food your fish should get accustomed to it and will keep you from un necessarily shopping for "gourmet" food.

Although down the road you can get fancy with quality frozen for a treat and some unseasoned nori but for starters I would go basic Good quality like Hikari. Pre-wet the food in your fingers so it will somewhat sink(the flake)



Fish Finally, fish should be added, in the smallest numbers. They are the largest consumers of food, and therefore produce the most waste. Having only a few fish will mean that you will be putting in less commercial food. This reduces the risk of food going uneaten and accumulating in the prefilter, possibly becoming food for algae and/or leading to diminished water quality. Your fish should be reef-compatible only; that is, they should eat algae but not coral.
  • 1 brittle star 1 serpent star They are ok, hide allot though so you probably will never see them. My preference is the chocolate chip again others have said they eat corals Not IME. Also "cool" looking they eat allot of algae at least mine do and get around the tank very well they are not as shy as the others this is a picture of the CC star and hippo tang(blue) sailfin desjardi and a yellow tang funny... I can look to the right and see the same fish swimming around



  • I'm getting some nasty brown algae growth on all bare areas of the live rock. It's really ugly... is it removable?

    Are you using a RO or DI??? you should... This could be a temporary algae cycle situation... BUT if it persists you may have to consider TWP tap water purification. Untill then you can / should remove the algae with a plastic bottle brush as I describe in SRK



    Tap water purification IMO is a very important , necessary and a significant additional cost to the set-up. I would strongly advise a DI or RO along with carbon pre filters before the actual purification. Using DI or RO will greatly reduce any problems with micro algae (the bane of reef tanks) it also allows IMO the high quality saltmix to better dissolve and release its beneficial trace elements along with yielding a known pH on a regular basis. Personally I prefer the DI, it does produce a lower quality of water than a RO however I find it to be more than acceptable.

    For the algae do you have a water purifier? RO or DI? Is it of sufficient size? Do you change the resin? Membrane? Do you have carbon pre-filters before the RO / DI ? I have found that using a quality water purification system takes care of most algae problems in a preventative natural way. You cant underestimate the importance of purified water!

    I think when you get your own TWP tap water purification you should notice a difference with the algae. Also Because you don’t dose kalkwasser (you should) that may have an effect on encouraging algae kalk keeps the pH high like 8.2 to 8.4 and is overall good for the tank I know you use other calcium additives but I would recommend kalk.Dosed as I described in the book just my opinion.

    I have a 200 with 375 lbs of rock set up with a custom eggcrate frame and spraybar 45 gallon sump 6 fish 6 or 8 corals and a bunch of inverts. It took 2 men working all day 10+ hours to take down move and re setup I only moved about 1/2 hour away My biggest mistake was when I mixed up my NSW My resin in my DI was expended and I didn't know it. I did about a 50% WC with bad water, hair algae followed and so did more WC with fresh DI water. Double check the resin before making up a large batch of SW.

    SURFACE SKIMMING

    ON the surface of the water there is growing a green type of algae. I've skimmed it off before, which cleans it up quite good, but it returns in a matter of 2 days! It gets quite stagnant and really restricts water surface movement. Any solutions?

    You should be "surface skimming" meaning ALL the water to feed your protein skimmer or filter should be taken from the surface of the tank. This is usually done with an overflow box or the tank drilled with a fitting through the top back wall so as the water is getting pumped into the tank...it then overflows into this fitting or overflow box. So the water to feed the skimmer is taken from the surface and will eliminate your problem. This is the method used in 99% of reef systems



    Yes despite what anyone says acrylic scratches MUCH more easily than glass! Another problem is when coralline algae grows on it, it is very difficult to remove and takes ALLOT more work to clean than glass

    The rock is Fiji. No invertebrates or other life has been added yet You didn’t say if you are using Purified tap water That sounds to me like the problem Is the tank cycled? ammonia nitrite nitrate are you getting a nitrate reading? This sounds like brown diatom algae typically common but not with bubble algae or green undesirable algae green and bubble is usually caused by silicates and or phosphate in the water which a reverse osmosis or deionizer will remove everything else in your system sounds great also you should be dosing with kalkwasser for your make up water ie:evaporation
    MAIN PG PREVIEW GET THE BOOK CRITICS SURVEY INDEX GUESTBOOK THE AUTHOR
    MAIN PG Your tools Awesome Links! Your tanks Your survey Order Now