What does that mean "you haven't had success with live rock"? What has happened?
No I wouldn't bother with any additives such as algebegone or the like. Brown diatoms are common, fortunately they are easy to remove. The brown algae (diatoms) should only be seem on the glass on sand. Its common to have to clean the glass weekly to remove this. Use a strong algae magnet. Ideally you should be using ro or di water lights for reef use only (they contain the proper spectrum) good water turn over 7 - 10x per hour volume of tank good protein skimmer Are you using ro or di water? How old is the tank?
Humm well that dosnt sound like it would crash the tank
That's a problem, I've always emphasized the importance of a backup system (generator) Reef tanks are very expensive and with all the work that goes in... make its more so
That's important.. you should have a quality twp in place
That's good advise, you have to be patient. I would guess getting the water and its cost would in the long run be more expensive than your current method.
Overall reef tanks are very expensive and if you try and cut corners where you shouldn't you can get bad results. see my survey for an average cost of a tank. I suppose the main question is where have you gotten your information from? Who's methods did you subscribe to? I cant really give you any answers to why your tank is the way it is. Possibly, it can be fine and this diatom outbreak is temporary (which is very likely) although I don't think you have an overall grasp of reefkeeping. I don't mean that in a derogatory manner but from the sound of your questions I think you need to get some detailed information and apply it. My book governs all the aspects of reefkeeping in an easy to comprehend manner.
The short answer, keep doing what your doing and the diatom will probably subside. Don't use the additive to get rid of it. And be patient, definitely consider investing in my book